Subject: Net Neutrality
From: Pratik Agarwal
Date: 31-Mar-15 7:44 PM
To: "advqos@trai.gov.in" <advqos@trai.gov.in>

Hi,

I, hereby, vote in favor of Net Neutrality wanting ISPs and Telecom Industries to provide us the same data speed and quality irrespective of the user, connection, website or content. I personally feel this is a violation of basic rights and it is high team TRAI considers this and take action in favor of the public and general consent.

Three basic points of neutrality:

  1. All sites must be equally accessible
    ISPs and telecom operators shouldn't block certain or apps just because they don't pay them. They should also not create gateways which influence discovery of sites, giving preference to some sites over others. Therefore,Internet.org is bad (explained @Zuckerberg’s sucker punch: Would you want free internet if it wasn’t really free?), and in India, Airtel OneTouch is bad (explained @Move over Internet.org: Airtel launches its own gateway to the Internet ), and there shouldn't be licensing of Internet companies (see @TRAI Chairman: Telco’s & Internet co’s need to find models of working together without destroying value). You don't want you Internet access to become as limited as your Cable TV service
  2. All sites must be accessible at the same speed.  
    This means no speeding up of certain sites because of business deals (see @YouTube Caught in Net Neutrality Flap in India). More importantly, it means no slowing down some sites. (see @This hilarious graph of Netflix speeds shows the importance of net neutrality)
  3. The cost of access must be the same for all sites (per Kb/Mb or as per data plan)
    This means no "Zero Rating". This applies to Wikipedia (see @Wikipedia Partners Aircel To Offer Free Access ) and Twitter (see @Vodafone’s Free Twitter Partnership In India Blows Up In Its Face ). In countries like India, Net Neutrality is more about cost of access than speed of access, because, well, we don't have fast and slow lanes. Given the paucity of 3G spectrum and a very poor, sparse wireline network, we have only slow lanes.
At a conceptual level, this means that Internet services compete with each other on the basis of product (or even marketing $$), and the consumer experience will not be determined by how the telecom operator or ISP distinguishes between Internet companies or apps. 

By keeping access neutral, we're:


I would really appreciate TRAI and other government bodies going along in favor of the customers.

Pratik Agarwal

AP Application Development

Global Information Services, Caterpillar India

Mobile : +91 8861994811

Email : Agarwal_Pratik@cat.com